Alejandro was made temporary team captain by Noah and chose the name Team Mahatma and chose the color blue. While they lost, they voted off Carrie for being inactive. He was then on known of as "Dat Muttiner"
Alejandro only had one line saying "Seriously?" when Chris said the challenge was catching a gorilla. He was captured by the gorilla and saved by Samuel. He voted Katelyn.
Alejandro and Gramps went to a funeral, leaving the Excelsiors handicapped, however the Excelsiors still beat the Mahatmas.
Alejandro was voted off first in the double elimination, but didn't have any lines.